STAR Flow, Chirality and Vorticity PWG

["Ma, Rongrong" <marr AT bnl.gov>]

Dear PAs, members of GPC #332, #337

Thanks very much for preparing slides and participating in today's 
discussion, which really helped to push both papers forward. Here are the 
questions as mentioned during the meeting. Please provide answers before Jan. 
4th. 

1) Do you agree with the essence of the following big-picture message for the 
two papers: the Hall effect dominates in 10-40% centrality while 
Faraday+Coulomb dominates in peripheral collisions? 

A related question: can we defend this physics message as a collaboration? 
Are we aware of any models/calculations that state such a centrality 
dependence is not possible?

2) Are you open to combine both analyses into one paper? If not, are you open 
to submit both papers to the same journal? If so, which journal(s) do you 
recommend?

3) If you prefer to have two papers, please send out your proposed abstract, 
conclusion, and relevant discussions of the other analysis for your own 
paper, taking into account today's discussion and question 1), 

Let's see responses from both GPCs, and hopefully we can converge soon. 
Thanks!

Best
Rongrong