STAR Flow, Chirality and Vorticity PWG

[Chunjian Zhang <chun-jian.zhang AT stonybrook.edu>]

Dear experts,

Hi. Based on our recent study, I have one comment on the CME paper Glauber 
fit.

I could not find any hints that the Glauber fit was scaled by a factor to 
match the STAR multiplicity trend. To me, it’s a misleading that I would like 
to believe and be surprised that the case3 describe the tend so well. (I 
believe the outside people will also have the same opinion as mine) I do 
think the CME author and experts need to consider mention this in the revised 
CME paper when you comment on the referee reports. 

Thank you and best regards 
Chunjian