sphenix-l AT lists.bnl.gov

Subject: sPHENIX is a new detector at RHIC.

List archive

Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document

From: "Sickles, Anne M" <sickles AT illinois.edu>
To: Gunther M Roland <rolandg AT mit.edu>
Cc: "sphenix-l AT lists.bnl.gov" <sphenix-l AT lists.bnl.gov>
Subject: Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document
Date: Mon, 23 Oct 2017 23:02:03 +0000

Hi all,

I would like to second the comments from Aaron that more detailed studies are needed to fully understand the impact on the range of our physics from the various scenarios. I believe this goes along with the sense of the EC meeting last week that we would like to keep our options open to the greatest extent possible within the options we have outlined and this should be very clear in the document.

I also agree with Jamie and Ron’s wording suggestions regarding the wording of the particle flow sentence.

Best,

Anne

On Oct 23, 2017, at 5:54 PM, Gunther M Roland <rolandg AT mit.edu> wrote:

A friendly reminder that comments on this important document are still being accepted! Thanks to everyone who shared their thoughts/corrections already. We will work on an updated draft tomorrow and then take it from there.

Best,

Gunther and Dave

On Oct 21, 2017, at 12:02 AM, Gunther M Roland <rolandg AT mit.edu> wrote:

Friends,

As discussed at the General Meeting today, we are forwarding draft 1 of our document outlining the detector scope for a $32M cost cap. The pdf file can be found at
https://www.dropbox.com/s/5wyutbndogozm5q/sPH-GEN-2017-002_v1.pdf?dl=0
(we'll provide another link tomorrow for those that can't access dropbox)

Please send your comments in reply to this mail, keeping the [sPH-GEN-2017-002] tag in the subject line***. Comments received by close-of-business on Monday, 10/23, will be most useful.

Cheers,

Gunther and Dave

***we will move future reviews to an sphenix-notes-l AT bnl.gov list, but the list couldn't be generated in time for this note.
_______________________________________________
sPHENIX-l mailing list
sPHENIX-l AT lists.bnl.gov
https://lists.bnl.gov/mailman/listinfo/sphenix-l

_______________________________________________
sPHENIX-l mailing list
sPHENIX-l AT lists.bnl.gov
https://lists.bnl.gov/mailman/listinfo/sphenix-l

Anne Sickles

Assistant Professor

University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign

sickles AT illinois.edu

[Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Gunther M Roland, 10/21/2017
- Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, David Morrison, 10/22/2017
- Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Martin Purschke, 10/22/2017
  - Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Nils Feege, 10/23/2017
  - Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, John Lajoie, 10/23/2017
  - Message not available
    - Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Jamie Nagle, 10/23/2017
      - Message not available
        
        Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Aaron Angerami, 10/23/2017
        
        Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, John Lajoie, 10/23/2017
- Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Soltz, Ron, 10/23/2017
- Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Gunther M Roland, 10/23/2017
  - Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Sickles, Anne M, 10/23/2017
  - Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Marzia Rosati, 10/23/2017
    - Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Gunther M Roland, 10/23/2017
- Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Aidala, Christine, 10/23/2017
- Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, John Haggerty, 10/24/2017
  - Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Rosi Reed, 10/24/2017
    - Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, woody, 10/24/2017
      - Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Gunther M Roland, 10/24/2017
        
        Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Rosi Reed, 10/24/2017
        
        Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, John Haggerty, 10/24/2017
        
        Re: [Sphenix-l] [sPH-GEN-2017-002] Collaboration comments on 2017 descoping document, Edward Kistenev, 10/24/2017